
The Broken Gavel, Fenwick
The Broken Gavel, Fenwick
Some of the best spots in Niagara aren’t in the big cities. They’re tucked into small towns like Fenwick, where everybody knows everybody and the local pub is where the community comes together. That’s exactly why The Broken Gavel made the list for one of the very first Must See Mondays.
Back in spring 2017, Must See Mondays was brand new. The idea was simple: knowing the Niagara real estate market is my job, but knowing the best places to eat and hang out in the communities I sell in is just as important. When you’re thinking about moving to a town, you want to know where you’re going to grab a bite, catch up with friends and feel at home. So every Monday I picked a spot I personally recommend and took you there with me.
A Fenwick favourite
The Broken Gavel is one of those places you walk into once and end up coming back to. This was one of our earliest, shortest episodes, so it’s a quick look around rather than a full sit-down feast, but it captures what makes the spot worth a visit: a relaxed, small-town atmosphere in the heart of Pelham, good food, and cold drinks.
If you’ve never spent time in Fenwick, it’s worth the drive. It’s a quiet, friendly corner of the Niagara Region, and The Broken Gavel is a great excuse to stop in.
Why it’s a Must See
Small-town spots like this are the heart of Niagara. Swing by, grab a seat, and tell ’em Joe sent you.
Episode at a glance
- Where: The Broken Gavel, Fenwick, Ontario
- Episode: Season 1, Episode 4
- Runtime: About 2 minutes
This episode originally aired in May 2017. Menus, prices and details may have changed since filming, so check ahead before you visit.



