
Don Marco's Italian Eatery, Welland
Don Marco's Italian Eatery, Welland
On this Must See Monday I went back to one of my favourite restaurants and one of my very first Must See Mondays: Don Marco’s Italian Eatery in Welland. The first time was way back in Season 1, Episode 2. This time I came to see one of my favourite restaurant owners, Lucy Ventresca, who had a special chef’s tasting menu planned just for me. My brother came along, which was a good thing given how much food came out.
Polenta fries
We started with polenta fries over tomato sauce and pesto oil, topped with garlic aioli, mozzarella and Parmesan. Delicious.
Fresh bread, oil and balsamic
A simple touch, but one I love: fresh Italian bread with olive oil and balsamic vinegar for dipping. I grew up eating this. Simple and amazing.
Stuffed hot banana peppers
Then one of my favourite appetizers anywhere: hot banana peppers stuffed with sausage and ricotta in tomato sauce. The fun part is that some peppers are sweeter and some are spicier, so every one is a surprise.
Homemade gnocchi
Next came Lucy’s homemade gnocchi, made fresh that day from a hundred-year-old family recipe. So soft I barely had to chew, in a tomato sauce with a hint of bacon. I wasn’t sure I was going to share this one. Thank you, Lucy’s grandma.
Fettuccine Florentine
Then fettuccine Florentine in a pesto cream sauce. Hot, creamy and so good.
New York strip loin
Here’s something I’d never had at Don Marco’s: steak. Every time I come I end up ordering pasta, but this New York strip loin in their house Marsala sauce with mushrooms, roasted potatoes and vegetables was unbelievable. So tender. I can’t believe I’d never ordered it before.
Tiramisu and espresso
We finished with tiramisu and an espresso. I love tiramisu, and this one was gooey, rich and delicious.
Why it’s a Must See
Thank you, Lucy, Lisa and the whole kitchen team at Don Marco’s. We had dishes I’d never tried there before, that steak was to die for, and the gnocchi alone is worth the trip. Come on down and let Lucy know Joe sent you.
Episode at a glance
- Where: Don Marco’s Italian Eatery, Welland, Ontario
- Host: Owner Lucy Ventresca
- What we ate: Polenta fries, bread with oil and balsamic, stuffed hot banana peppers, homemade gnocchi, fettuccine Florentine, New York strip loin with Marsala sauce, tiramisu
- Episode: Season 2, Episode 16
- Watch first: Don Marco’s, Season 1
This episode originally aired in July 2018. Menus, prices and details may have changed since filming, so check ahead before you visit.



