
Cracker Jacks Bar & Grill, Thorold
Cracker Jacks Bar & Grill, Thorold
Rain, sleet or snow, Must See Monday goes on. On this episode I headed to Thorold to see my good buddy Tony, who was reopening Cracker Jacks Bar & Grill. It’s been a go-to spot in Thorold for years, even back when I was in school at Brock. I’d heard the renovations were beautiful and the new menu kept all the classics.
Meatballs
With a cold beer waiting on the table, we started with meatballs: soft inside, a little crisp and browned outside, with sauce and cheese. Delicious.
Buffalo chicken poutine
Next, one of their three poutines: the buffalo chicken poutine. Crispy fries, cheese curds, cheddar and gravy, topped with a fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce and blue cheese. Get the chicken, blue cheese, fries and gravy all in one bite. I never would have thought to put that on a poutine, and the combination is unreal.
Meat lovers pizza
Then an individual meat lovers pizza with sausage, bacon and pepperoni. A carnivore’s dream come true: crunchy bacon, juicy sausage and plenty of cheese.
The famous wings
Cracker Jacks built its reputation on chicken wings, and believe it or not this was the first time I’d had wings on a Must See Monday. Little Joe fact: wings are one of my favourite foods. These are a healthy size, not the puny ones you get on some wing nights. Medium sauce, blue cheese on the side. Good stuff.
The sirloin burger
Then the sirloin burger: Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar, bacon, sauteed mushrooms, onions, lettuce and tomato on a toasted bun. Huge. I have a big mouth and I wasn’t sure it was big enough. One of the juiciest burgers I’ve had.
Chicken cavatappi
To finish, spiral cavatappi noodles in a cream sauce with roasted red peppers, topped with a breaded chicken breast and hot sauce. It tastes almost like a chicken wing mac and cheese. I was sweating. It was kind of like a workout.
Why it’s a Must See
Thank you, Tony, for having me at the newly renovated Cracker Jacks. The place looks beautiful, and the menu is outstanding. Head on down to Thorold and tell Tony that Joe sent you.
Episode at a glance
- Where: Cracker Jacks Bar & Grill, Thorold, Ontario
- What we ate: Meatballs, buffalo chicken poutine, meat lovers pizza, Cracker Jacks wings, sirloin burger, chicken cavatappi
- Episode: Season 3, Episode 13
This episode originally aired in January 2019. Menus, prices and details may have changed since filming, so check ahead before you visit.



